I have a somewhat rocky relationship with Butter London, which I expounded in a somewhat blistering fashion in a previous BL review. But I’ve been on a bit of a BL spree in the last several months, what with BOGOs at Ulta and 50% coupons off of already reduced last orders on their website. In spite of myself, I’ve begun to love it. I still don’t love it $15 for 11ml worth, but I really love it at $8.00 and under…
This is Queen Vic, which BL calls a red wine/cranberry creme. I only had a few BL cremes in my collection previously, but I’ve gotten quite a few more with my latest acquisitions. For the most part I’ve liked them, I find them better than China Glaze, but not quite up to OPI standards. I’d put them just under Zoya, which might be attributed to the brush.
I’d classify this more as a berry than a cranberry, which I think of as more red. Maybe red wine/dark mauve as it does lean just a taste purple. I find it very close to OPI Anti-Bleak from their one of of their Mariah Carey offerings a few years ago or Casino Royale from the Skyfall collection. Also Got Cherried Away from the Coca-Cola collection, which I actually have. I’ll need to remember to do a comparison when I get around to reviewing that one. Or maybe Zoya’s Veronica.
In other words, there’s nothing unique or special about the color. Well, I shouldn’t say not special, because the color itself is a great one. Probably why there are so many variants of the shade available. Work appropriate but not boring, understated but not granny-ish, attractive on just about every skin tone and any nail length. In other words, a pretty classic shade and one that I’m quite fond of in general, not just in nail varnish.
Big Apple Red made its debut in the New York Collection way back in 2000 and has since become a classic in the line. It’s easy to see why, it’s a classic middle of the road red, nice opacity and shine and, of course that famous OPI smooth as a dream creme formula.
But it enough? I don’t know. I’m on a perpetual search for The Perfect Red. Although red is one of my favorite colors, I don’t really wear a lot of red polish. I think it’s because for so long there weren’t many options in nail varnish and red was pretty much the default go-to. Plus I can’t wear red unless my nails are fairly long because short, stubby nails + short, stubby fingers + red polish = man hands.
So, while Big Apple Red was the closest for quite some while to my dream red, it wasn’t quite there. And I only have it in a mini because I couldn’t quite commit to a full size bottle of a color I don’t wear that much when the search was still on. That’s also why the bottle shot shows Seche Vite instead. The mini is too small to really show but a bottle is something to hang onto so you don’t relapse into Claw Hand.
As you can see, this was one of the 70% of times that I forget to wrap the edges. Pro-tip: If you’re wearing red, make a real effort to remember to make it the 30% that you remember to wrap because it’s a lot more noticeable than with a lighter color!
What keeps this from being The One? It’s a nice clear, true red but I think it leans just a skosh blue. And, while I’ll take a red that leans blue over a red that leans orange every day and twice on Sunday, it’s not The Perfect Red. I’d also like it to be just a tad more squishy, like a crelly rather than a straight creme. But, it’s shiny glossy and fabulous so I highly recommend it for someone that isn’t as picky as me.
I’ve since gotten a couple of candidates that just might be The Perfect Red, but I need to compare them head to head. I think at some point I’ll do an entire post consisting of the Tournament of the Reds. I’ll need to wait a bit longer until my nails grow out a little more so I can go all Dragon Lady Style with it and quite possibly crown an Ultimate Grand Supreme Empress of the Reds!